May 16, 2007

Comparing Fox’s GOP Debate With MSNBC’s (VIDEO)

by MsUnderestimated — Categories: 2008 Campaign, Don'tcha Just Love It?, Telling It Like it Is, Video10 Comments

Wow. Just wow. NRO blogger, Stephen Spruiell, has put together a brilliant video to compare the quality of questions from the MSNBC debate versus the Fox News debate. I’ve been trying to think all day of a way to make this comparison in words, but when I found Spruiell’s blog post & video this evening, I was blown away. I couldn’t have done any better than he did, and you should share this with everyone you know.

Here’s an excerpt from Spruiell’s post:

So how do the questions from the first GOP debate, moderated by MSNBC and the Politico.com, match up to the questions posed by the FOX News panel in the second debate?

It’s not even close. Opening up the Media Blog vault and reviewing the first GOP debate after having just watched the second was a revealing exercise. I think the MSNBC/Politico questions actually got stupider with age.

By contrast, the FOX News questions were serious and the questioners tenacious in pursuing answers. Even the questions that viewers submitted to FOX via e-mail were far better than “What do you dislike most about America?” and the other nonsense that got past the Politico’s electronic gatekeepers.

This also might explain the DNC’s recent decision, according to MediaBistro, to shun Fox News altogether in their future debate schedule.

The Democratic National Committee has officially announced “the dates, media sponsors and cities for the six DNC sanctioned debates.”

CNN and NBC get two and ABC and CBS get one each. Fox News isn’t included. Here’s the list:

    July 23, 2007: YouTube/Google and CNN in Charleston, SC

    August 19, 2007: ABC in Des Moines, IA

    September 26, 2007: NBC News/MSNBC in Hanover, NH

    October 30, 2007: NBC News/MSNBC in Philadelphia, PA

    November 15, 2007: CNN in Las Vegas, NV

    December 10, 2007: CBS in Los Angeles, CA

Just can’t take the possibility they might actually be asked a tough question, can they? For anybody who may be even THINKING about voting Democrat, you’ve got to ask yourself this one question: If the Democrats are afraid to answer honest, tough questions by conservatives, how then will they deal with Al Qaeda, Iran, North Korea, Syria, China, et. al? Oh, that’s right… they’ll just appease them. It is, after all, America’s fault, isn’t it? Besides, the real answer is…they have no answer; only criticism of President Bush. Last time I checked, extreme hatred of one person or party never accomplished anything at all. It only makes people more bitter about life in general.

Oh, and one last “funny” from the debate last night. I caught this still shot of the panel (Hume, Wallace and Goler) after Ron Paul’s assertions that the U.S.A. was somehow partly responsible for 9/11.

Heh. That’s how I look every time I hear Pelosi or Reid speak.

  • Jeb

    Who cares if the Dems shun FOX? Screw ‘em.

    Should the Republicans do a debate with Air America?

  • http://www.msunderestimated.com MsUnderestimated

    So you are comparing Fox News to Air America? Not even in the same league. So tell me.. when was the last time Brit Hume did an on-air “joke” about shooting the President? Air America has no listeners, and Fox News is the leader in cable news by far and away. The liberals are just scared to death to face legitimate questions, unlike the “what do you like least about America?” crap spewed by Chris Matthews at the MSNBC “debate.”

    Jeb, you lost what little credibility you had, if any.

  • orion

    I’d like to see a debate with Al Franken as the moderator. Won’t happen, they’d rather have a love fest and call it a debate on Fox News. And by the way, if you call Matthews liberal, you are nuts.

  • orion

    Nice editing, by the way. Lemmings.

  • http://amyproctor.squarespace.com Amy Proctor

    The Fox News moderators were head and shoulders above the other debate moderators thus far. The questions were serious, the counterquestions poignant…. it was a professional debate thanks to the moderators.

    The screen cap you posted above is at the moment Rudy Giuliani responded to Ron Paul. I was surprised the moderators let him respond but they must have known the comments begged a response.

  • LTCPMax

    actually…in what I think is the second time in last 9-12 months.. I agree with Orion on one small point.

    I would really like to see AL FRANKEN involved in a debate with the Republican candidates. Give him enough exposure to demonstrate what an analytical lightweight he really is. Air America (especially now post Franken) doesn’t even have a recognizable name “celebrity” anymore, nor any credible journalists to conduct a reasonable debate. OH, and just a small reality check JEB, but Air America is RADIO…. and FOX NEWS is a HUGE TELEVISION NETWORK. In the last 20 or so years, political debates tend to be TELEVISED, not just on radio (although it is sometimes simulcast on radio, I concede)

  • LTCPMax

    actually…in what I think is the second time in last 9-12 months.. I agree with Orion on one small point.

    I would really like to see AL FRANKEN involved in a debate with the Republican candidates. Give him enough media exposure to demonstrate what an analytical lightweight he really is. Air America (especially now post Franken) doesn’t even have a recognizable name “celebrity” anymore, nor any credible journalists to conduct a reasonable debate.

    A great potential moderator that I would suggest, would be Senator Joe Lieberman.

    OH, and just a small reality check JEB, but Air America is RADIO…. and FOX NEWS is a HUGE TELEVISION NETWORK. In the last 20 or so years, political debates tend to be TELEVISED, not just on radio (although it is sometimes simulcast on radio, I concede)

  • orion
  • orion’s mom

    Only by lead paint chewing son couldn’t see the difference between hard questions during the Fox debate an the other MSM duffs.

    orion you promised to look for a job today! By the way you can keep Al Franken.

    The man is a nut job with a temper.
    http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=8900992849057210175&q=al+franken&hl=en

    Then there is Al Franken lying about a Golda Meir quote on Tough Crowd with Colin Quinn. FYI, youtube pulled all the tough crowd videos.
    http://www.frankenlies.com/lies/toughcrowd.htm

    Moderator? Maybe if he gives back the money that Air America stole from the New York Boys and Girls club.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQA0kOZdvf8

  • Moshker

    Maybe I’m biased, but I’ve seen a lot of indications of Fox’s conservative slant on news, though I would agree that their debate was much better than the msnbc debate.

    Little of this matters anyway since the primary delegates are going to be picked by party bosses doing deals in back rooms anyway. Does your state have a primary vote? Does the party in your state have to apportion delegates accordingly? Mine doesn’t.

© 2012 MsUnderestimated All rights reserved - Wallow theme v0.46.5 by ([][]) TwoBeers - Powered by WordPress - Have fun!